This sounds about right:

The EU’s approach to digital regulation can be seen as an autoimmune reaction—an overactive institutional response that targets its own thriving digital ecosystem. In an effort to safeguard fundamental rights, competition, and democratic values, the EU often imposes sweeping regulatory frameworks that end up stifling innovation, burdening domestic platforms, and inadvertently entrenching foreign tech giants with greater compliance capacity. Like an immune system attacking healthy tissue out of caution or confusion, the EU risks weakening its digital resilience by treating internal actors as threats rather than nurturing them as vital components of a healthy digital future.

In contrast, the U.S. approach to digital regulation resembles an open ecosystem overwhelmed by invasive species—most notably, unchecked AI development. Prioritizing rapid innovation and market dominance, the U.S. has allowed powerful technologies to proliferate with minimal oversight, often at the expense of social cohesion, labor stability, and democratic norms. Like invasive species introduced into an unprotected environment, AI systems are reshaping the landscape, outcompeting traditional institutions, disrupting local industries, and eroding trust in information and governance. While this laissez-faire model fuels short-term growth, it risks long-term degradation of the ecosystem it was meant to empower.

Neither the EU’s autoimmune-like overregulation nor the U.S.’s laissez-faire embrace of invasive digital forces is inherently good or bad—they each reflect different instincts for preserving sovereignty and promoting innovation. However, both extremes carry systemic risks: one can paralyze growth through overcorrection, while the other may allow unchecked expansion that erodes foundational structures. A balanced approach is needed—one that fosters innovation while safeguarding public interest, cultivates resilience without rigidity, and recognizes that healthy ecosystems require both protection and adaptability to thrive in the digital age.

This post and comments are published on Nostr.